The Sneakily Important Virtue College Students Might Be Overlooking
Father Gregory Pine's campus talk, hosted by NDSU’s Thomistic Institute in Minard Hall, offered a reminder that flourishing in college isn't about doing everything, but learning how to make good decisions
Grace Leier/ The SpectrumCollege is full of decisions. From deciding which classes to take and which organizations to join to figuring out whether to accept another commitment when our schedules are already packed, we are constantly choosing how to spend our time. Yet, how often do we actually stop and think about how we make those decisions?
That was the question I found myself reflecting on after attending Fr. Gregory Pine's campus talk, “A Sneakily Important Virtue to Flourish in College.” The virtue at the center of his presentation was prudence, something that might not immediately come to mind when we think about succeeding in college. We often associate success with discipline, ambition, hard work and involvement. But Fr. Pine made a compelling case for why prudence deserves just as much attention.
Prudence is often understood as practical wisdom: the ability to recognize what is good and choose the right way to pursue it. It is not simply being cautious or avoiding risks. Rather, it is learning how to think clearly, evaluate situations and make decisions that reflect what is genuinely good.
One helpful way to understand prudence is through the process of making a decision. It involves three important movements: deliberation, judgment and action.
First, deliberate movement. Before making a decision, we need to take the time to consider the situation. What are the circumstances? What are our responsibilities? What are the possible options, and what might follow from each one? Instead of immediately reacting to a request or opportunity, prudence asks us to pause and think.
Second, judgement. After considering the options, we need to determine which one is actually best. Not every good opportunity is the right opportunity, and not every option that's appealing is necessarily wise. This requires us to consider our priorities and recognize that our decisions have consequences.
Finally, action. A good decision requires more than thinking about what we should do. We have to follow through. Prudence means putting our judgment into practice rather than remaining stuck in indecision. These steps sound straightforward, but applying them to everyday college life can be surprisingly difficult.
One of my favorite takeaways from Fr. Pine's talk was his point about wanting to become someone who, when asked to do something, does not immediately respond with an overwhelmed “Ahhh!” Instead, he wants to thoughtfully answer based on what he already has going on. I found this especially relatable. How many times have we agreed to something without checking our schedules, only to realize we have three other commitments that day? How often do we say yes because we do not want to disappoint someone or miss out on an opportunity?
I think this is where prudence becomes particularly important for college students. We are surrounded by opportunities to get involved, meet people, serve our communities and grow professionally. These are all wonderful things, but being involved in everything does not necessarily mean we are making the best use of our time.
Prudence teaches us that saying no is not always a bad thing. Sometimes, the wiser decision is recognizing that we have already made commitments that deserve our attention. It is possible to want to help someone while acknowledging that we cannot take on another responsibility at that moment. It is possible to be ambitious without overextending yourself. Sometimes saying no to one thing will help you give 100% to something that will help you flourish.
Another important distinction is that prudence is not about becoming indecisive or overthinking every little thing. It is about developing the ability to make thoughtful decisions and act on them confidently. We should not need to panic every time someone asks something of us. Ideally, we should know our priorities well enough to give a reasonable answer.
He also mentions that it is important to recognize that prudence is not about optimizing every aspect of our lives. College students can easily fall into the mindset that every hour needs to be productive, every opportunity needs to be taken and every decision needs to bring us closer to some larger goal. But life is not a productivity competition. Sometimes, the prudent decision is to take a break, spend time with a friend, be present with the people around us or allow ourselves to do something simply because it is good and enjoyable. Prudence is not about squeezing the most out of every moment; it is about recognizing what each moment calls for and responding accordingly.
I walked into the talk thinking I would just be learning about another virtue, but I left considering how much it influences the ordinary decisions I make every day. It challenged me to be more intentional with my time, more thoughtful about my commitments and less inclined to say yes simply because an opportunity presents itself.
College is a time to explore, take chances and make the most of new experiences. But perhaps flourishing is not about how much we manage to fit into four years; it is about the kind of people we become through the decisions we make along the way.
Prudence might be a sneakily important virtue, but it is one worth practicing. After all, the goal is not to become someone who can do everything. It is to become someone who knows how to choose what is worth doing.
More in opinion
OpinionThe Book is Always Better
Why movie adaptations struggle to capture the magic of the original story
OpinionCold and Cozy: The Love of Winter Comfy Culture
Why are we so obsessed with being comfy in the winter?
OpinionFour Things Modern Society Could Stand to Bring Back
There are many traditions that didn’t deserve to die out