Thanksgiving Without a Hotdish?
A North Dakota transplant investigates Midwestern Thanksgiving
Jess WiseAs a Midwestern transplant from Georgia, I’ve spent four years learning that hotdish is one word and that a salad may contain absolutely no vegetables.
I’ve tried Oreo and Snickers salads, and I’m still recovering from the textures. After discovering lefse, knoephla soup and puppy chow, I expected a North Dakota Thanksgiving to feature such regional curiosities. I asked three NDSU colleagues what they serve each year, and no one mentioned tater tot hotdish. Instead, there was turkey. Lots of turkey and green bean casserole.
Jenn Anderton, data and communication manager in NDSU’s Office of Admission, has celebrated Thanksgiving in South Dakota, Montana, Moorhead and Fargo. For more than 20 years, her family’s Thanksgiving dinners have started at 4 p.m. The menu? A 23-pound turkey, stuffing and green bean casserole made from the same recipe. No ham allowed.
When I suggested calling it “green bean hotdish,” Anderton was emphatic. “GREEN BEAN HOTDISH? Absolutely not,” she wrote. Sarah Fischer, senior admission officer, explained that, to her, a hotdish should contain a protein.
As a Georgia native, I wondered why green bean casserole was acceptable while “tater tot casserole” sounded so wrong. Carolina Pettus, assistant director in the Office of Admission, said she’d never noticed the inconsistency. I remain unconvinced that the distinction is logical, although I’m beginning to understand that logic may not be the governing principle here.
Tradition has its own rules. We call dishes what our families have always called them, and we often make them the way our family always has. For instance, Fischer’s family eats pizza the night before Thanksgiving. On Thanksgiving evening, they watch “A Charlie Brown Thanksgiving” and recreate the meal from the cartoon.
Pettus grew up in Lincoln, Nebraska, where her family hosted graduate students and speech team members who couldn’t travel home. Her family served rutabaga pudding, a Scandinavian dish she described as “one of the worst things.” Later, she celebrated with relatives in Minnesota. This year she’s experimenting with a new recipe for stuffing, a side dish that has long been a family staple.
When I asked what Thanksgiving meant beyond the food, all three agreed: family.
My Georgia siblings who’ve migrated here would agree, although green bean casserole never made it to our table. As children, we had turkey, deviled eggs, mustard-forward potato salad, noodles cooked in turkey drippings and white giblet gravy. Those recipes came north with my siblings and me. My youngest sibling, Glo, knows how to cook them. I specialize in eating them.
NDSU has its own Thanksgiving tradition on Thursday, Nov. 19. Dining centers will serve turkey, sage dressing, mashed potatoes, cranberry sauce and lefse, among other dishes. Dinner runs from 4-7:30 p.m. at the Residence Dining Center and 5-8:30 p.m. at West Dining Center. West Dining Center will also offer an allergen-free menu, and both locations will have cheese tortellini with marinara sauce available upon request.
I plan to enjoy the campus meal, and perhaps finally try lefse, before sticking to our family recipes on Thanksgiving Day.
Anderton also volunteered at last year’s NDSU Friendsgiving, where she noticed that few guests came alone. Many arrived with spouses, children and friends. “While they may not have been with all the family they wanted, they were still with a family,” she said.
I wonder what other families are serving in the apartments around mine. How many have brought their favorite recipes from somewhere else? Our Thanksgiving table will have turkey, potato salad and deviled eggs, just as it did in Georgia.
As for green bean hotdish, I’m still not convinced. Please don’t tell my coworkers.
More in variety
VarietyFall in Seoul, South Korea
The fall colors in Seoul and around Korea are in full bloom, slowly but surely shedding and giving way to colorful piles and bare branches
VarietyThe Holidays of November
Covering the lesser-known November holidays from other countries, cultures and religions
Variety