Chelsea Follet Challenges Views of the Past at NDSU
Cato Institute researcher discusses historical living conditions and the advancement of technology

Photo by Samantha ButlerModern conveniences such as electricity, medical care and accessible food are often taken for granted, but life before industrialization looked significantly different, according to Chelsea Follett, a research fellow at the Cato Institute.
Follett spoke at North Dakota State University on Friday, Nov. 13, as part of the Human Progress and Flourishing Workshop hosted by the Sheila and Robert Challey Institute for Global Innovation and Growth. Her presentation, "The Grim Old Days: An Introduction to the Preindustrial Past," explored the challenges of everyday life before industrialization and the advancements that have shaped modern society.
The event took place from 10 to 11 a.m. in Beckwith Recital Hall, with a virtual attendance option available through Zoom.
Follett, who works with HumanProgress.org, discussed the themes of her book, "The Grim Old Days: An Introduction to the Preindustrial Past." The book examines historical living conditions and argues that economic growth, technological innovation and expanding opportunities have improved the quality of life for much of the world's population.
Throughout her presentation, Follett challenged the tendency to romanticize the past, particularly the idea that preindustrial communities enjoyed simpler, healthier and more peaceful lives.
"We all have these overly romanticized views of the preindustrial world, this green paradise," Follett said.
She explained that popular depictions of historical societies often overlook the difficulties people faced, including disease, poor sanitation, limited medical care and food insecurity.
According to Follett, the average person living before industrialization worked in subsistence agriculture, producing enough food to survive but often little beyond that. Without modern agricultural technology, families depended heavily on physical labor and remained vulnerable to crop failures and famine.
She also emphasized the prevalence of childhood mortality, explaining that many families experienced the loss of one or more children.
Medical care was another central topic of the presentation. Follett described how common treatments could cause additional harm, using the death of George Washington as an example of historical medical practices.
Washington underwent extensive bloodletting during his final illness, a treatment commonly used by physicians at the time. Follett argued that the example demonstrated how medical interventions could worsen patients' conditions rather than improve them.
Dental care presented similar challenges. Follett described historical tooth extractions performed without modern anesthetics or antibiotics, explaining that dental problems could become dangerous when infections went untreated.
"In the days before antibiotics, even a small infection or cut could prove deadly," Follett said.
Beyond health care, Follett discussed the lack of sanitation and adequate housing in many historical communities.
She described overcrowded living conditions, poor waste disposal and limited access to clean environments. Even wealthy households and royal residences, she explained, faced sanitation problems that would be considered unacceptable by modern standards.
Follett also challenged the perception that life before industrialization was more peaceful. She discussed historical rates of violence and argued that physical punishment, including violence against family members and workers, was more widely accepted in many past societies.
The treatment of animals was another example Follett used to illustrate changing social attitudes. She described historical practices such as bull-baiting, in which dogs were used to attack bulls for public entertainment.
Follett argued that growing attention to animal welfare reflects the changes in society's expectations about the treatment of living creatures.
Throughout the presentation, she connected these historical examples to the broader argument that industrialization helped improve living standards.
Although industrialization is frequently associated with difficult working conditions and child labor, Follett argued that many of those hardships existed long before factories became widespread.
"Child labor didn't originate with the Industrial Revolution. It was preexisting," Follett said.
She maintained that industrialization and subsequent economic growth contributed to reducing poverty and expanding access to resources, eventually allowing more people to pursue opportunities beyond subsistence labor.
Follett also addressed how political perspectives can influence perceptions of history. She argued that romanticized views of the preindustrial world exist across the political spectrum, although they may take different forms.
According to Follett, some individuals idealize historical economic and social hierarchies, while others envision a preindustrial society characterized by environmental sustainability and greater harmony with nature.
She challenged both interpretations, arguing that historical evidence reveals a more complicated picture of life before modern economic development.
As the presentation shifted toward the future, Follett discussed the potential for technological advancements to continue improving living conditions.
She expressed optimism about artificial intelligence and automation, comparing their potential effects to earlier innovations that reduced the amount of labor required for everyday tasks.
However, Follett also raised concerns about regulations that she believes could restrict technological development, including limitations on data center construction and emerging technologies.
"Progress is not inevitable," Follett said.
She argued that economic and technological progress should not be viewed as guaranteed, emphasizing the importance of policies and institutions that allow innovation.
Following the presentation, audience members asked questions about Follett's research, political polarization and the future of technological advancement.
One attendee asked how artificial intelligence could affect employment as technology becomes capable of performing tasks traditionally completed by humans.
Follett responded by comparing the potential changes to the transformation of agricultural employment following industrialization. She explained that advances in agricultural productivity reduced the number of workers needed to produce food, allowing people to pursue employment in other industries.
Although Follett acknowledged that artificial intelligence could eliminate certain jobs, she expressed optimism that technological advancements would create new opportunities and increase productivity.
"I do believe some jobs will go away, but I believe more jobs will be created ultimately than destroyed," Follett said.
Another attendee asked whether people romanticize the past because of political polarization.
Follett responded that nostalgia extends beyond political ideology, explaining that people across the political spectrum may hold idealized perceptions of earlier generations.
"I do not think it's just the far left and the far right," Follett said.
She also addressed nostalgia for more recent decades, including the 1980s and 1990s, arguing that people may overlook the technological conveniences and opportunities that have developed since those periods.
Follett acknowledged that modern society continues to face challenges, particularly concerning the affordability of housing, education and health care. However, she emphasized that those challenges should be considered alongside the broader historical improvements in living conditions.
"The challenges of the modern world are real," Follett said.
The presentation concluded with a book signing, followed by refreshments and appetizers for attendees. The first 100 guests were offered complimentary copies of Follett's book.
The Human Progress and Flourishing Workshop brings researchers and speakers to NDSU to discuss economic opportunity, innovation and policies affecting individual and societal well-being. The series is open to students and community members, with students also able to participate through a one-credit course.
Follett's presentation encouraged attendees to reconsider how they view the past and recognize the advancements that have shaped modern life, while examining the conditions necessary for continued progress.


