The Book is Always Better
Why movie adaptations struggle to capture the magic of the original story
Alayna Gilsrud/ The SpectrumHow many times have you heard someone say “The book was better” after being so excited their favorite novel was coming to the screen? There is a type of thrill when seeing your favorite characters brought to life, only to be disappointed when it isn't quite what you expected. Books are generally better than their movie adaptations because they can dive deeper, grow storylines and develop characters. In addition, there is a personal connection we share with so many books.
The biggest limitation of movie features is that they can't possibly include everything. Books have hundreds of pages, whereas a movie gets about two hours to unfold. Movie directors have to decide what stays and what goes. As readers, ALL of those details are important and add to the story. While reading a book, you aren't limited in the “important details.” The little things that make novels so great are often cut or shortened. In my opinion, removing or changing details negatively impacts the overall story and changes how consumers view the plot.
In a novel, we are able to understand and connect with the characters. Typically, reading allows readers to know what the characters are thinking and feeling. In a movie, these important details can feel rushed when we spend 400 pages getting to know the characters, just to see one clip in a film. Many things are left to the imagination when forced to communicate through dialogue and facial expressions rather than thoughts and emotions. It's one thing to watch a character experience something difficult, but it's another to spend chapters understanding exactly how that experience affects them.
Reading a story is such a unique experience. Authors can create amazing pieces, leaving room for each reader's own mental picture of characters, scenes or settings. What makes this diverse is how two people can read the same book and have completely different worlds come to life. Creating a movie adaptation takes away some of the reader's creativity. Selecting certain actors, costumes and locations makes it difficult to enjoy a film when you already have formed an idea of the story.
For example, I had a very hard time watching the movie adaptation of “It Ends With Us” by Colleen Hoover. Not only were important details missing, but the outfits of the actors were not at all what I had anticipated when reading the book. Instead, these simple details made it hard for me to like the film.
While movies and books can both be enjoyable, it is simply hard to top a great novel. On their own, movie adaptations are great but limit the time, storytelling and attachment we get from books. This doesn’t mean I won’t watch (and be irritated) when a book becomes a movie. At the end of the day, a movie might be able to recreate the story, but it can't always recreate the experience of reading it.
More in opinion
OpinionCold and Cozy: The Love of Winter Comfy Culture
Why are we so obsessed with being comfy in the winter?
OpinionFour Things Modern Society Could Stand to Bring Back
There are many traditions that didn’t deserve to die out
OpinionThe Silent Power of What You Wear
“Clothes shouldn’t be restricted. They are supposed to feel comfortable and make a person feel like their individual selves.”