Are you paying more for the same item?
The North Dakota State Collegiate Future Farmers of America and NDSU Collegiate Farm Bureau hosted a food information forum to discuss pertinent topics in the agriculture and food industries as part of Ag Week on April 10.
A panel of four experts discussed how modern U.S. labeling uses a confusing system.
The panel and audiences discussed differences between genetically modified organisms (GMO) and non-GMO products, specific definitions of agricultural products, different laws between states about product labeling and differences between conventional, organic and all-natural farming.
One of the panelists,
“There isn’t a lot that is actually made with GMOs that we consume directly, but everything is labeled non-GMO,” Pahl said. “The reasoning behind that is so they can charge a premium with (the label).”
A lot of consumer products that say non-GMO don’t have GMOs in them in the first place.Dahltin Pahl
Pahl expressed his concern behind the modern issue of fear-based labeling and the matter of how important it is for consumers to be educated about the product they are consuming.
“The GMO movement, especially, isn’t necessarily labeled the right way,” Pahl said. “A lot of the consumer products that say non-GMO don’t have GMOs in them in the first place.”
Currently, the U.S. only allows 10 crops to be genetically modified. They are squash, soybeans, corn, cotton, papaya, canola, alfalfa, sugar beets, potatoes and apples.
Panelists also discussed problems with food labeling laws that go beyond GMOs. Currently, there is no federal law that restricts the labeling of the food product.
All four panelists agreed that consistency is important and the process of proper labeling will take time due to the paper process.
“I live right along the North Dakota and South Dakota border. So, if I’m in one state buying something and if it’s labeled differently, then it’s exactly the same product in South Dakota, I’m going to assume there is a difference in the products when there isn’t,” Pahl said.
Mark Jirik, director of Northern Crops Institute, pointed out the flaws of organic labeling. He shared the story about an organic farmer he used to do a business with.
“There was a loophole in the organic law. If you could not get enough organic feed to feed your cows, then you can still label them as organic,” Jirik said. “If you’re looking at 10,000 cattle, (this farmer) was getting enough organic feed for maybe 500 of them, and this went on for multiple years.”